my Analytics, Media and Marketing blog      |  my Yahoo! Web Analytics Book     

Home /

My immediate thoughts on Digital Magazines – after buying the Kindle

- by Dennis R. Mortensen. Sunday, January 10, 2010 email  print   share

ywa-kindle-dennis-mortensenAs I have stated repeatedly over the last year or so – I am obsessed with the state of News Media and in particular how Analytics, in that regard, can help publishers increase their current performance. This post is nothing more than exciting boyish musings, that does little to validate my conclusions. Anywho, this is my blog! :-)

I was really excited to receive a Kindle the other day, as I finally got to actively try out a new reading experience in regards to my above fixation. If you think about it, kindle, or similar e-reader experiences, like what B&N or Sony peddle, provides the opportunity to deliver a digital magazine, while actually capturing a set of metrics. Still limited and few, but metrics nonetheless. My first set of purchases was (of course) Data Driven Insights with Yahoo Analytics, but also the Economist Magazine (both Amazon kindle links).

Like you, I am most sure, I tag into an endless stream of information (news), flowing in from RSS feeds, Twitter and so on and so forth. I even believe that I am somewhat selective in my limited 28 RSS feeds, following 57 folks on twitter etc. – BUT still en endless information stream nevertheless. I personally see that as somewhat of an issue, never being able tick a box and say that you are finished.

The first positive element about e-readers, speak directly to the above issue, which is that, it creates, just as with a traditional magazine (in paper), the feeling of having consumed and completed a task. I don’t believe this is a bad feeling to emulate in digital magazines. I for one have the interest and willingness to consume an editorial package that goes beyond the actual article. There is a huge difference between me letting a friend know that the December edition of Wired Magazine was really cool, as compared to me sharing a link to Evan Ratliff’s Vanish Article (which just adds to the endless stream).

The first negative element about current digital magazines on e-readers, is that they bring nothing to the party, above and beyond what I get from the printed magazine. They almost detract from what I have gotten used to from their online editions. Where I have the audio interview, the video extension, the additional pictures that didn’t fit to print etc.

Conclusion (day 3):
I honestly believe that a tablet of some sorts will provide the opportunity for a prospering digital magazine industry, I in particular see the need for a curated editorial product that can be consumed, completed and finally commented on as a whole. Everything that seems like a task - MUST create a structure to finish, which is my biggest issue with today’s endless information stream. However, I believe the digital magazine is up for a transformation which is more radical than the print replica I just read.

Please note that this comment is, of course, not about the hardware, but about the digital magazine concept. It is also difficult to figure out to what extent data mining and traditional analytics is being used in driving the digital edition – seems like NOT at all on the Kindle today (in the eye of the publisher, I am sure Amazon is mining the hell out of usage patterns). Well, more about this subject later, when I get even wiser.

Interesting digital magazine prototypes (video demos), especially the Mag+ presentations from Bonnier:

(Please have in mind that my experience is limited to me having access to a kindle and the Economist for a few days, so don’t be shy in adding to the discussion, I would love to hear about your immediate experiences)

Cheers :-)
/ Dennis (@dennismortensen)


6 Comments:

  1. Eric Hamilton Says:

    Dennis,
    Very interesting and I agree
    I don’t own a Kindle or any EBook reading device, but if these devices function as “text storage devices” then they are NOT truly taking advantage of the possibilities.

    I wrote about the a similar topic a few months ago:
    http://eham1906.blogspot.com/2009/11/down-with-newspapers.html

    I see a prescription model as the savior for magazines and newspapers. I would be willing to pay $20 per month for unlimited Kindle wireless access to every magazine and newspaper in the U.S.

  2. Akin Says:

    Not having tried e-readers myself, I was wondering whether they add any hyperlinks to mags / books? Doesn’t sound like it.

    For example, reading Ulysses, every 3d word could be hyperlink’d to explain something that I don’t know. In such way the e-reader would add value over the paper version.

    But where then is the difference to the WWW you might ask. Also, adding such hyperlinks might remove that feeling of having accomplished a task as you felt yourself seeking. Since everything will be interconnected I mean.

    So maybe instead of hyperlinks, the ability to doubleclick a word and get a Wikipedia or normal human translation for it when you really need to.

    And if I do that more than 10 times per page on Ulysses the e-book self-destroys and auto-enrolls me in evening adult school, English class.

    Have a good week in NY!

  3. James Dutton Says:

    @dennis glad you bought the Kindle! you’ll not look back now, in fact you’ll probably spend considerably more on books as it’s one-click purchase! I guess the only disappointing thing with the Kindle in the US is having people *pay* for rss feeds. ridiculous!

  4. Dennis R. Mortensen Says:

    Hey Akin

    The Kindle actually does include a dictionary, but it seems more of a “Reading a book” add-on to me, and less of a Digital Magazine feature. It also includes the opportunity to connect to outside links (such as deployed in books like yours and mine), which is not a bad feature at all.

    This linking feature of course only work, when and if magazines like the Economist start aggressively linking out - and if not that, then cross linking to other articles. They are not there yet.

    I’ll endeavor to have a great week in NY. Cold. But GREAT! :-)

    cheers
    d.

  5. Dennis R. Mortensen Says:

    Hi James,

    I keep quoting you about the spend increase, as you “warned” me early on, when people pitch me the $9.99 book price.

    - YES! but you buy more than twice the amount mate! :-)

    Cheers
    d.

  6. Dennis R. Mortensen Says:

    Hi Eric,

    I do agree that a subscription business model might actually emerge again, with the introduction of digital readers. The cool thing about this, is that we will actually see this play out as we speak. This is not a faraway future, this is literally happening today.

    d. :-)

Comment: